When Citation Fails: Essay

* journal writing essay
[2026-01-11 Sun]

1. Introduction

  • Describe a common academic practice: students writing claims first and attaching citations afterward.
  • .Clarify that the issue is not plagiarism or citation format.

  • State the central thesis narrowly:

    This practice represents an epistemic failure because it reverses the proper direction of justification, transforming sources from generative constraints into rhetorical shields.

2. What Is Knowledge?

  • Define the normative standard before judging student behavior.

2.1. Knowledge Requires Justification at the Time of Formation

  • A belief qualifies as knowledge only if it is justified when held, not retroactively.
  • Clarify justification
  • Without this principle, the term knowledge collapses into mere belief plus endorsement.

2.2. Directionality of Justification

  • Evidence → Interpretation → Claim not Claim → Citation

3. Failure

  • Identify the precise failure mechanism.

3.1. Description of the classmate Pattern

  • Claims formed from:
    • intuition
    • memory
    • classroom generalities
    • other sources(skimmed)
  • Sources attached later to:
    • satisfy rubrics
    • signal credibility

3.2. Epistemic Invalidity

  • A source used after belief formation:
    • pcannot have constrained wording
    • cannot have limited scope
    • cannot have reduced confidence
  • If the source did not cause the claim to take its form, it is not functioning as evidence.

3.3. The Missing Warrant

  • A warrant explains how a source supports a claim.
  • In student writing, citations function as black boxes.
  • Result: arguments become epistemically opaque and uninspectable.

3.4. From Inquiry to Rhetoric

  • The goal shifts from truth-seeking to appearing supported.
  • This is a failure of epistemic responsibility, not merely a writing error.
  • Incentive structures reward compliance over inquiry.

4. Conclusion

  • The core problem is an epistemic inversion, not improper citation.
  • Restoring inquiry requires treating sources as generative causes of claims.

5. Elsewhere

5.1. References

5.2. In my garden

Notes that link to this note (AKA backlinks).

Recent changes. Attachment Index Tag Index Bibliography Index Source.