AI assignment threats to biodiversity
* school ecology assignment1. Gemini Guided Learning Prompt & Cross-Reflection
1.1. Original Prompt
I am a Grade 9 student and I need to learn about the five major threats to biodiversity. I want to use your guided learning feature to understand them. Please ask me questions to help me learn about the following topics: 1) habitat removal and alteration, 2) global warming, 3) overharvesting and exploitation, 4) pollution, and 5) introduction of non- native species. For each topic, I need to know what the human activity is, why it is a problem, and what can be done to help. I also want to learn about the concept of environmental stewardship.
1.2. Response
1.2.1. Topic 1: Habitat Removal and Alteration
This is widely considered the single greatest threat to biodiversity on Earth. It isn't just about destroying a home; it's about breaking up the connections nature needs to survive (often called fragmentation).
To kick off our learning session, I want you to think about why we remove habitats.
- Question 1
We often think of "habitat loss" as cutting down forests to build cities or shopping malls. However, there is a different human activity that is actually the #1 cause of habitat destruction worldwide.
- Topic 1: Habitat Removal and Alternation(continued)
- Habitat Removal and Alteration
- Human Activity:
- Clearing land for agriculture (farming/ranching), forestry (logging), and urban development (housing/roads).
- Damming rivers, which alters aquatic habitats.
- Why it is a problem:
- It directly removes the food, shelter, and breeding grounds species need.
- Fragmentation: It breaks large habitats into small, isolated "islands," making it hard for animals to find mates or migrate.
- What can be done:
- Preservation: Creating protected parks and reserves.
- Restoration: Replanting forests and restoring wetlands.
- Human Activity:
Sustainable Agriculture: Farming in ways that leave space for nature (like leaving hedgerows between fields).
- Habitat Removal and Alteration
- Notes
- Human activity can damage habitats.
- This damages local ecosystems and removes necessary ressources for the local animals
- Fragmentation can break large habitats into smaller ones, this makes it harder for animals to mate or migrate
- We can stop this by protecting parks and reserves, replanting forests and restoring wetlands. We can also farm in ways that leave space for nature
- Cross-reference
- Habitat Loss, the Dynamics of Biodiversity, and a Conservation Challenge
- Author: Ilkka Hanski (et al.)
- Publication: Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B (2011)
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3357798/
- What did gemini get right?
- The scientific article states that habitat loss has been, and still is, the greatest threat to biodiversity worldwide, especially due to human activities like land conversion.
- The paper discusses how species disappear when their habitats shrink below levels needed for survival. This corroborates the point that animals lose food, shelter, and breeding grounds.
- What did gemini get wrong or miss?
- The article explains not just that habitat loss is harmful, but that ecosystems can reach tipping points where populations collapse if habitat falls below a certain amount. This scientific detail wasn’t mentioned in the AI explanation and adds depth to understanding the threat.
1.2.2. Topic 2: Global Warming
Global warming refers to the rapid increase in the Earth's average temperature. This is driven by the "Greenhouse Effect," where gases like Carbon Dioxide (CO2) trap heat in our atmosphere. Nature usually changes very slowly over thousands of years, giving animals time to adapt. However, human-driven global warming is happening very fast.
- Question 1:
If the climate changes too quickly for a species to evolve or adapt, what are the only two options left for that species to survive? (Think about what you would do if your house suddenly became too hot to live in.)
- Topic 2: Global Warming (continued)
You identified the two main survival strategies!
- Migrate: Move toward the poles or higher up mountains to find cooler air.
- Adapt: Change their behavior (e.g., hunting at night) or physical traits over time.
Here is the catch: Because climate change is happening so fast right now, most species cannot evolve quickly enough to adapt. And many cannot migrate (like a Polar Bear running out of ice, or a fish in a warming lake). If they fail to do either, they face extinction.
- Human Activity:
- Burning fossil fuels (coal, oil, gas) for energy and transportation releases Carbon Dioxide (CO2) and Methane.
- Deforestation (trees absorb CO2, so cutting them down releases it back into the air).
- Why it is a problem:
- Speed: Temperatures are rising faster than species can adapt.
- Habitat Loss: Melting sea ice (affects polar bears), rising sea levels (floods coastal habitats), and warming oceans (kills coral reefs).
- What can be done:
- Reduce Emissions: Walk/bike/bus instead of driving, use energy-efficient appliances.
- Renewable Energy: Switch to wind, solar, or hydro power.
- Reforestation: Planting trees to absorb carbon.
- Notes
- Combustion releases CO2 and Methane
- Deforestation removes a major carbon sink
- Temperatures are rising extremely fast
- Sea levels are rising and many aquatic habitats are being destroyed
- We can try to prevent this by staying efficient with our energy usage
- We can also switch to renewable energy sources
- We can replant trees to absorb more carbon
1.2.3. Topic 3: Overharvesting and Exploitation
This threat is all about taking too much, too fast. We often treat nature like an unlimited grocery store, but the shelves don't restock instantly. Historically, humans have hunted some species until they were gone forever (like the Dodo bird) or almost gone (like the American Bison).
- Question
Today, the biggest overharvesting problem isn't on land; it is in the oceans. Why is "overfishing" considered a threat to the entire ocean ecosystem, rather than just a problem for the specific fish we are eating (like Tuna or Cod)?
- Topic 3: Overharvesting and Exploitation(Continued)
You nailed it again. You have correctly identified the three main reasons why overfishing destroys more than just the fish on our dinner plates.
Here is the breakdown of the concepts you just described (these are excellent terms to use in a Grade 9 assignment):
- "Other fish rely on them" (Food Webs): This is called a Trophic Cascade. If you take too many Tuna (predators) out of the ocean, the population of the fish they eat (prey) explodes, which can eat up all the plankton, causing the whole system to crash.
- "Other ones are caught in the way" (Bycatch): This is the technical term for when nets accidentally catch animals we didn't mean to, like sea turtles, dolphins, and baby fish. They are usually thrown back dead.
- "Giant net fishing" (Bottom Trawling): This is when massive weighted nets are dragged along the sea floor. As you noted, this destroys the habitat (corals and sponges) that baby fish need to hide and grow.
Here is your summary for Topic 3:
- Overharvesting and Exploitation
- Human Activity:
- Overfishing: Taking fish faster than they can reproduce.
- Poaching: Illegal hunting of animals for trophies (e.g., elephant ivory) or traditional medicine.
- Bottom Trawling: Dragging heavy nets across the sea floor.
- Why it is a problem:
- Population Collapse: Species like Cod or Tuna can be wiped out commercially.
- Bycatch: Killing non-target species (turtles, dolphins) disrupts the ecosystem.
- Ghost Fishing: Abandoned fishing gear continues to trap and kill animals for years.
- What can be done:
- Quotas: Laws that limit how many fish can be caught.
- Marine Protected Areas (MPAs): Zones where fishing is banned so fish can breed.
- Consumer Choice: Buying "Sustainably Certified" seafood (look for the blue MSC label).
- Human Activity:
- Notes
- Killing small fish kills the food source for the predators and killing big fish causes the population of the prey to rise
- We sometimes catch animals we dont mean to and then throw them out
- Bottom trawling destroys habitats
- We can prevent this by limiting how much fish can be caught, creating areas where fishing is banned, and buying sustainably certified seafood.
- Cross-Reference
- https://www.longdom.org/open-access/the-impact-of-overfishing-on-marine-ecosystems-99707.html
- Author: L. Wright
- The Impact of Overfishing on Marine Ecosystems
- Published: Poultry, Fish & Wildlife Sciences (2023)
- What did gemini get right?
- The article states that overfishing means fishing too many fish so that populations cannot replenish themselves. This confirms Gemini's point earlier.
- Wright explains that when fish populations decline, other species that depend on them are affected, disrupting the marine food web. This matches Gemini’s explanation about food webs and ecosystem effects
- What did gemini miss or get wrong?
- Gemini did not fully extand the extent of ecosystem imbalance. The source provides broader consequences such as entire ecosystem imbalance and potential extinction risk for fish species.
1.2.4. Topic 4: Pollution
Pollution is introducing harmful contaminants into the natural environment. We often think of visible trash, but invisible pollution is often more dangerous.
- Question
Question 4: Imagine a factory dumps a small amount of mercury (a toxic metal) into a lake.
- The algae absorb a tiny bit.
- The tiny bugs eat lots of algae.
- The small fish eat lots of bugs.
- The big fish (like Pike or Trout) eat lots of small fish.
- Topic 4: Pollution(cont;)
Exactly! You’ve described the process of Biomagnification perfectly. In a food chain, energy is lost as you go up (the 10% rule), but certain toxins—like mercury or the pesticide DDT—don't disappear. Because a big fish must eat hundreds of small fish to survive, it ends up absorbing all the poison those small fish ever ate.
Here is your summary for Topic 4: Pollution
- Human Activity:
- Chemical Runoff: Pesticides and fertilizers from farms wash into rivers.
- Industrial Waste: Factories releasing heavy metals (mercury, lead) or plastics into the air and water.
- Litter: Plastics that break down into "microplastics" and enter the food chain.
- Why it is a problem:
- Biomagnification: Toxins become more concentrated at the top of the food chain, poisoning top predators (and humans!).
- Eutrophication: Fertilizer runoff causes "algal blooms" that suck all the oxygen out of the water, creating "dead zones" where fish suffocate.
- What can be done:
- Regulation: Governments passing laws to limit what factories can dump.
- Organic Farming: Reducing the use of synthetic pesticides.
- Proper Disposal: Never pouring chemicals (like paint or oil) down the drain.
- Human Activity:
- Notes
- Humans cause pollution
- Pollutant levels are more concentrated at the top of food chains
- Fertilizer runoff causes "algal blooms" from that suck oxygen from water and suffocate fish(see: Denitrification)
1.2.5. Topic 5: Introduction of Non-Native Species
This is sometimes called the "Invasive Species" problem. It happens when humans move a species to a new part of the world where it doesn't belong. Usually, in a healthy ecosystem, every animal has a natural predator that keeps its population in check (for example, wolves keep deer populations from getting too big).
- Question
When a non-native "Invasive Species" arrives in a new place, why do they often take over so quickly and wipe out the local species? (Hint: Think about what they are missing in their new home.)
- Topic 5: Introduction of Non-Native Species(cont;)
Exactly! Since they have no natural predators to hunt them and no natural diseases to slow them down, their population explodes. They are like a team playing a sports match where the other side doesn't show up—they win every time.
Here is your summary for Topic 5:
- Human Activity:
- Accidental: Species "hitchhiking" in the ballast water of ships, on the bottom of hiking boots, or in shipping crates.
- Intentional: Releasing pets (like goldfish or pythons) into the wild, or bringing in plants for gardens that later escape into the forest.
- Why it is a problem:
- Competition: They take the food, water, and space that native species need to survive.
- Predation: They may eat native species that have no way to defend themselves.
- No "Checks and Balances": Without predators to regulate them, they can take over an entire ecosystem, leading to a loss of biodiversity.
- What can be done:
- Prevention: Cleaning boats and boots before moving to new areas and never releasing pets into the wild.
- Management: Physically removing the species (pulling invasive weeds) or using "biological controls" (introducing a predator from their home country, though this is very risky!).
- Human Activity:
- Notes
- Invasive species increase competition and eat defenseless native species.
- There are no predators to regulate them, so they can dominate ecosystems
- We can stop this by preventing invasive species from coming to areas and removing invasive species
1.2.6. Topic 6: Environmental Stewardship
Now that we have covered the five threats, we end with the solution: Environmental Stewardship.
Stewardship is the idea that humans are not just "users" of the Earth, but caretakers. It means managing our natural resources responsibly so that the environment remains healthy for future generations. It’s moving from a mindset of "What can I take?" to "How can I take care of this?"
- Question
Your Final Challenge: Think about your own school or neighborhood. Based on the five threats we just discussed (Habitat, Climate, Overharvesting, Pollution, Invasives)…
What is one specific "Stewardship Action" you could take this week to help reduce one of these threats? (For example: "I will use a reusable water bottle to reduce Pollution.")
- Topic 6: Environmental Stewardship(cont;)
When you choose to bike or walk, you are directly reducing the amount of CO2 entering the atmosphere. When you turn off lights, you reduce the demand for power plants to burn coal or gas. These small individual choices, when multiplied by millions of people, are exactly how we begin to solve these large global problems.
2. Reflection Questions
2.1. Was using the AI's guided learning feature a useful way to learn about this topic? Explain your answer with at least two specific reasons. (e.g., "The AI helped me because…", "The AI was not helpful for me because..").
Yes, it was useful.The AI explained topics step by step and asked questions that helped me think.
2.2. What was the most helpful part of the AI's response or conversation?
The most helpful part was the questions and explanations after each answer. They helped me understand exactly why each threat is a problem.
2.3. What was the least helpful or most confusing part of the AI's response or conversation?
Gemini used terminology I was unfamiliar with like "trophic cascade" and "bycatch". I needed to reread a few explanations to fully understand them.
2.4. Based on your experience, do you think AI tools like this could be a good resource for learning in school? Why or why not?
Not really. it is much easier for me to learn from a source where all the information is visible right away.
2.5. The AI likely discussed solutions for the threats. Choose one of the five threats and propose a solution that could be implemented at a local community level.
- Threat: Pollution
- A local solution is organizing community clean-ups and making initiatives to reduce plastic use.
- This helps keep pollution out of rivers and habitats.
2.6. You read about environmental stewardship. Think about the concept of reduce, reuse, and recycle. Which of the five threats to biodiversity does this concept directly help to mitigate? Explain your reasoning.
- Reduce, reuse, and recycle helps reduce pollution.
- It lowers waste and prevents harmful materials from entering ecosystems.
3. Elsewhere
3.1. References
3.2. In my garden
Notes that link to this note (AKA backlinks).
